Captive vs. Non-Captive Insurance Agents: What Is the Difference?

By Kris Keush, Founder & CEO of American Legacy Insurance Group

Captive agents sell for one company. Non-captive (independent) agents can sell for many. Here is how the two compare and why many agents choose to stay independent.

Never Captive: Your Book Stays Yours

Watch: Never Captive: Your Book Stays Yours

Captive agents

  • Represent one insurance company and its products.
  • Often get leads, an office or a salary from that company.
  • Usually cannot sell other carriers' products.

Non-captive (independent) agents

  • Can be contracted with many carriers and compare options for each client.
  • Own their relationships with their clients.
  • Choose the FMO or agency that supports them, and can change if it is not working.

Questions to ask

  • Can I leave, and what happens to my clients if I do?
  • Which carriers and products can I sell?
  • What tools and support do I get?

Questions agents ask

Can I switch from captive to independent?

Many agents do. Check your current contract for any limits before you move.

Is American Legacy Insurance Group captive?

No. Our contracts are non-captive, so you can walk away anytime.